Skip to content

Kentucky’s New Public Adjuster Law Raises a Troubling Question: Who Is Protecting the Policyholder?

A recent Kentucky court ruling has reignited a national debate about insurance claims, consumer protection, and the right of property owners to hire professional representation when dealing with their insurance companies.

When a homeowner or business owner suffers significant property damage, navigating the insurance claims process can be overwhelming. Insurance companies have trained adjusters, engineers, consultants, and legal professionals working to evaluate claims and protect their interests.

But what happens when the policyholder’s ability to hire an experienced professional to negotiate on their behalf is restricted?

That is the question at the center of a controversial new Kentucky law and a recent court decision that could have implications for the public adjusting profession nationwide.

At Sarasohn & Company, Inc., Public Adjusters Since 1924, we believe every policyholder deserves a fair opportunity to understand, document, and pursue the insurance benefits available under their policy.

And this case demonstrates why that principle matters.

What Happened in Kentucky? Understanding House Bill 568

In April 2026, Kentucky enacted House Bill 568 (HB 568), legislation that introduced significant restrictions on public insurance adjusters.

Among its most consequential provisions, the law:

  • Prohibits public adjusters from negotiating insurance claims directly with insurers on behalf of policyholders for two years.
  • Establishes a two-year moratorium on issuing new public adjuster licenses, subject to specified exceptions.
  • Introduces additional requirements governing public adjusting contracts, fees, and professional conduct.
  • Restricts certain relationships between public adjusters and contractors.

On October 28, 2026, Jefferson Circuit Court Judge Jessica E. Green dismissed a constitutional challenge to the legislation in Brandi Dawn Carroll, et al. v. Russell Coleman.

The dismissal was issued with prejudice and designated final and appealable.

Although the ruling represents a significant legal setback for the plaintiffs, it also raises a broader question for property owners across the country:

If an insurance company can employ professionals to negotiate a claim, why should a policyholder be restricted from hiring a licensed professional to do the same?

Insurance Company Adjusters and Public Adjusters: Understanding the Difference

One of the most important distinctions in the insurance claims process is something many policyholders do not fully understand.

An insurance company adjuster represents the insurance company. A public insurance adjuster represents the policyholder.

Insurance company adjusters investigate claims, assess damages, and evaluate payment obligations on behalf of their employers.

Public adjusters, by contrast, are licensed professionals retained by policyholders to assist with their property insurance claims.

Depending on applicable state law, a public adjuster may help with:

  • Identifying and documenting covered property damage.
  • Preparing detailed estimates of repair or replacement costs.
  • Reviewing claim documentation and payment calculations.
  • Identifying potentially overlooked damage or disputed scope items.
  • Assisting with the presentation and negotiation of insurance claims.
  • Helping policyholders understand the factual basis of their claimed losses.

This distinction is critical.

When an insurance company sends an adjuster to inspect a damaged property, that adjuster is not an independent advocate hired to protect the homeowner’s financial interests.

The adjuster is performing a professional function for the insurance company.

That does not mean insurance company adjusters necessarily act improperly. Many perform their duties professionally and in good faith.

But their role is fundamentally different from that of a public adjuster.

The question is not whether insurance companies should have adjusters. The question is whether policyholders should have access to qualified professionals representing their interests, too.

Why Restricting Public Adjusters Could Put Policyholders at a Disadvantage

Consider a homeowner whose property suffers significant hurricane damage.

The insurance company may have access to experienced claims professionals, estimating software, engineers, building consultants, and other resources.

The homeowner, meanwhile, may have never filed a major insurance claim.

They may not know how to evaluate whether an estimate accounts for all necessary repairs, whether damage has been overlooked, or whether the scope of work properly reflects the property’s condition.

That is one reason public adjusters exist.

A qualified public adjuster can bring experience in property damage assessment, construction estimating, insurance claim preparation, and claims negotiations to a process that may otherwise feel intimidating.

Kentucky’s new restriction creates a particularly troubling situation.

Under the law, a public adjuster may still perform certain services, including inspecting damages, preparing estimates, and advising policyholders. However, for the statutory two-year period, public adjusters are prohibited from negotiating directly with insurers on behalf of insureds.

In practical terms, a policyholder may be able to hire a professional to document the amount of a loss but not to negotiate that amount with the insurance company on their behalf.

This raises legitimate concerns about whether the restriction creates an imbalance in the claims process.

Consumer Protection Should Strengthen Policyholders’ Rights, Not Weaken Them

Supporters of stricter public adjusting regulations frequently emphasize consumer protection.

And appropriate regulation is important.

Public adjusters should be properly licensed, accountable, transparent about their fees, and prohibited from engaging in deceptive or abusive practices.

However, protecting consumers and restricting their access to professional representation are not necessarily the same thing.

Effective consumer protection should include professional standards, meaningful oversight, clear contractual disclosures, and appropriate consequences for misconduct.

It should also recognize that policyholders may benefit from experienced assistance when navigating complicated property insurance claims.

Insurance claims can involve disagreements over:

  • The full extent of covered property damage.
  • Whether repairs or replacements are necessary.
  • Appropriate construction methods and repair pricing.
  • Depreciation and replacement cost calculations.
  • Damage to commercial buildings, equipment, or business operations.
  • The amount of a covered loss.

These disagreements can have substantial financial consequences for property owners.

Removing a policyholder’s ability to retain a licensed public adjuster to negotiate those issues may make an already complex process even more challenging.

What Does Kentucky’s Court Ruling Mean for Florida Policyholders?

It is important to clarify that Kentucky’s House Bill 568 does not change Florida’s public adjusting laws.

Florida continues to regulate and license public insurance adjusters, who may assist policyholders with property insurance claims within the scope of their lawful authority.

For homeowners, condominium associations, commercial property owners, and businesses throughout Florida, the Kentucky decision nevertheless serves as an important reminder.

The ability to obtain professional assistance with an insurance claim should never be taken for granted.

Whether your property has suffered damage from a hurricane, windstorm, fire, water loss, or another covered event, having knowledgeable representation can make a meaningful difference in how your claim is documented, presented, and evaluated.

An insurance policy is a contract that establishes rights and obligations for both the insurer and the policyholder.

Understanding those rights, and properly supporting a claim, can be essential to pursuing the benefits owed under that contract.

Why Hiring a Public Adjuster Early in the Claims Process Matters

One of the most common mistakes property owners can make is waiting until a claim becomes disputed before seeking professional assistance.

By that point, inspections may have been completed, initial estimates prepared, payments issued, or important documentation overlooked.

While public adjusters can often assist after a claim has been filed, obtaining qualified help early may allow for a more organized and comprehensive claims process.

Early involvement can help ensure that:

1. Damage is thoroughly documented. Visible and potentially concealed damage can be evaluated before important evidence is lost or repairs change the property’s condition.

2. Repair estimates are properly prepared. The required scope of repairs and associated costs can be reviewed against the actual damage.

3. Claim documentation is organized. Photographs, inventories, estimates, and supporting records can be compiled for the insurer’s evaluation.

4. Potential disagreements are identified sooner. Differences between the insurer’s assessment and the policyholder’s documented loss can be recognized and addressed.

5. The policyholder has an experienced professional on their side. Rather than navigating every aspect of a complex claim alone, the insured can obtain assistance from someone familiar with the process.

No public adjuster can guarantee a particular settlement, and every claim remains subject to the policy’s terms, exclusions, limitations, and applicable law.

But qualified representation can help policyholders pursue a thorough and properly supported claim.

A Century of Advocating for Policyholders

Since 1924, Sarasohn & Company, Inc. has been part of the public adjusting profession, representing the interests of policyholders rather than insurance companies.

For more than a century, our company’s mission has centered on a straightforward principle:

When property owners suffer an insured loss, they deserve knowledgeable representation and a fair opportunity to recover the benefits available under their insurance policies.

The Kentucky ruling is a reminder that the role of public adjusters extends beyond preparing estimates and reviewing paperwork.

Public adjusting is about helping policyholders navigate one of the most challenging financial situations they may encounter.

And it is about ensuring that the insurance claims process is not a conversation in which only one side has professional representation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Public Adjusters and Kentucky HB 568

Can public adjusters still negotiate insurance claims in Kentucky?

Under Kentucky House Bill 568, public adjusters are prohibited from negotiating directly with insurers on behalf of insured policyholders for a two-year period beginning with the law’s April 13, 2026, effective date. Other authorized public adjusting services remain available, subject to statutory restrictions and any subsequent legal changes.

Did Kentucky ban public adjusters entirely?

No. HB 568 imposes significant restrictions, including a temporary negotiating prohibition and a two-year moratorium on issuing new public adjuster licenses, subject to exceptions. It does not completely eliminate all public adjusting services.

Is hiring a public adjuster legal in Florida?

Yes. Florida licenses and regulates public insurance adjusters. Licensed public adjusters may assist policyholders with insurance claims in accordance with Florida law.

What is the difference between a public adjuster and an insurance company adjuster?

An insurance company adjuster performs claims work for an insurer. A public adjuster is retained by the policyholder to assist with the policyholder’s insurance claim.

When should I hire a public adjuster after property damage?

Policyholders can benefit from consulting a licensed public adjuster early in the claims process, particularly when a loss is substantial, involves complicated repairs, or requires extensive documentation. A public adjuster may also assist with existing claims, subject to applicable law.

Can a public adjuster help with an underpaid insurance claim?

Yes. Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, a public adjuster may review an insurer’s estimate, identify disputed or overlooked damage, prepare supporting documentation, and assist in pursuing additional covered benefits. Additional payment is not guaranteed.

Final Thoughts: Who Is Really Looking Out for the Policyholder?

Kentucky’s public adjuster legislation and the recent court ruling have sparked an important conversation about consumer rights and the future of professional insurance claim representation.

Insurance companies have the resources to employ experienced professionals to evaluate and negotiate claims.

Policyholders should understand the importance of having access to qualified professionals who can advocate for their interests as well.

At Sarasohn & Company, Inc., we believe property owners deserve more than an insurance company estimate. They deserve a thorough evaluation of their loss and a fair opportunity to pursue the coverage they purchased.

If your home, business, or commercial property has suffered damage, do not assume the insurance company’s initial assessment tells the entire story.

Contact Sarasohn & Company, Inc. — Public Adjusters Since 1924 — to discuss your property insurance claim and learn how our team may be able to assist you.

Serving policyholders in Florida and other states where appropriately licensed.


Sources and further reading

This article provides general insurance information and commentary, not legal advice. Insurance laws and claim requirements vary by jurisdiction.

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *